Shifts in Design Habits: A Reflection on the Post-2007 Crisis, 2009
Written by Ezri Tarazi, 2009
For many, the economic crisis that began in 2007 seemed like just another fluctuation in the market—a routine dip in a cycle of booms and busts. Yet, as financial markets crumbled, governments intervened at an unprecedented scale, and the crisis spread rapidly across the globe, it became clear that this was no mere “temporary downturn.” Instead, it was a partial collapse of entire economic systems. The technical details of the crisis point to something deeper: this was not simply a financial malfunction, but a fundamental ideological and moral breakdown.
This crisis exposed the fragile extremes between individualism and collectivism, the hollow pursuit of endless consumer goods, and the surreal ethos of concentrated wealth. Even if the global stock markets begin to recover, for many who have lost their savings—or worse, their jobs—this will offer little comfort. A critical trust has been broken between capital systems and production systems, and without that trust, restarting the engines of growth in the same old way will be difficult, if not impossible. What is needed is a fundamental ethical shift in the global economic model—something that cannot be addressed by economics alone.
Designers and design managers, often seen as priests of consumer culture, must now confront this ethical transformation. The field of design is undergoing subtle but significant changes that are reshaping how people perceive consumption itself. Though cultural shifts of this magnitude take time, the year 2009 may well be remembered as a historical turning point in the evolution of global design.
Will people stop consuming? Certainly not. But gradually, the ethos of “conspicuous consumption”—cultivated by the European and especially American elite—will take a serious hit. The economic crisis is just one facet of a multifaceted global upheaval. We are also facing social, geopolitical, environmental, and even philosophical-religious crises. None of these has yet fully matured, but together, they are beginning to change how people—especially younger generations—think and act.
Organizations and companies that fail to internalize the depth and implications of this crisis will find themselves irrelevant. A change in values is beginning to simmer, altering the collective consciousness in irreversible ways. Design, as a significant cultural force embedded in human society, is uniquely positioned to respond to this change. Designers can and should become the standard-bearers of this transformation.
They do not need to passively await judgment, nor must they see themselves as mere cogs in the system. But what must change in our design habits? What are the ethical values we must now embrace? Here are several distilled suggestions:
• Less ostentation, more emotional wellbeing
• Less disposability, more sustainability
• Less luxury, more quality and longevity
• Less gloss, more honesty
• Less cleverness, more wisdom
• Less seduction, more loyalty
• Less, and that’s enough.
How should companies and organizations prepare for such a value shift in their operating assumptions? First, corporate growth habits must be re-evaluated. Rapid, unchecked expansion is risky; premature scaling is not inherently positive. Organizations must base their core values on long-term sustainability. Second, their product and service lines must reflect the changing social and psychological consciousness of their audiences. This requires deep and comprehensive innovation across the board, including:
• Products that conserve resources
• Products designed to last for years
• Products aligned with new lifestyles and values
• Products that are open to user customization and upgrades
• Products that communicate humility, simplicity, and quality
• Products that disappear from the retail field into integrated service ecosystems
“Designers don’t like design,” declared Murray Moss, the owner of the elite design store Moss in New York, in response to a piece in The Times suggesting that “design thrives in downturns.” Writing in The Observer, Moss argued that beauty remains vital, even during recession (“Design’s downturn? Not so fast,” The Observer, 2009). I tend to agree with him. But for me, beauty is not reserved for products priced in the thousands. High aesthetics can be found in basic, even inexpensive items—so long as they are well-crafted. Utility and practicality have never been barriers to beauty. I see great beauty in objects not crafted by designers, but designed for pure function. Yet even without romanticizing this, designers can focus their full attention on generating magic within constraints—of cost, function, and uncompromising quality.
The challenge for designers and design managers is formidable. Amid deep anxiety triggered by plummeting demand across nearly all sectors, they must convince their leadership to invest in the design and development of new products. In some cases, this means a dramatic shift in corporate strategic focus. The risk inherent in innovation is even greater during times of uncertainty—and design lies at the heart of innovation.
Design leaders must therefore exhibit true leadership, creatively and rigorously guiding their organizations toward sustainable transformation. This is not the time for overblown professional egos, nor is it the time to submit to data-obsessed executives waving ominous spreadsheets. It is a time for collaborative work that listens to a wider range of voices and considers more complex factors in strategic decision-making. Those who tune into the right signals and interpret change correctly will be the ones standing at the summit when the next wave of growth arrives.
References:
• Moss, Murray. “Design’s Downturn? Not So Fast.” The Observer, 2009.
• Ritzer, George. The McDonaldization of Society. SAGE Publications, 2008.
• Klein, Naomi. No Logo: Taking Aim at the Brand Bullies. Picador, 2009.
• Baudrillard, Jean. The Consumer Society: Myths and Structures. SAGE Publications, 1998.
• Raworth, Kate. Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist. Chelsea Green Publishing, 2017.
• Papanek, Victor. Design for the Real World: Human Ecology and Social Change. Thames & Hudson, 2005.
• Thackara, John. In the Bubble: Designing in a Complex World. MIT Press, 2006.
• Latour, Bruno. We Have Never Been Modern. Harvard University Press, 1993.
• Manzini, Ezio. Design, When Everybody Designs: An Introduction to Design for Social Innovation. MIT Press, 2015.
• Sennett, Richard. The Craftsman. Yale University Press, 2008.