Menu

Design in the Time of Terror, 2007

Design in the Time of Terror, 2007

Design in the Time of Terror – An Interview with Professor Dana Arieli, 2007

D.A. I’d like to begin our conversation with a question about design and social awareness. In your view, when and how does design encounter politics and society?

E.T.  Design reflects—almost entirely—the surface and subterranean currents of politics and society, as it is closely intertwined with economic and cultural systems. To deeply understand a society, one important parameter to examine is design, because it reveals aspects that verbal declarations often fail to express.

I perceive design as encompassing everything visual that we see and experience in the human-made world. While art has chosen to distance itself from everyday reality—retreating into the reflective spaces of the ‘white cubes’ of museums and galleries—design remains largely embedded in reality, since reality must be designed, in one way or another, by someone. In a ‘capitalist dictatorship’ like a shopping mall or a resort village, everything is meticulously designed to serve a specific agenda imposed by a ruling entity. In a ‘chaotic democracy’ such as the Ramla market, design is the product of naïve, individual efforts by all participants.

So if we were to simply walk down the street where we live, we would encounter the bench, the streetlight, the café logo, its furniture, the menu, the coffee cup, the spoon… we experience design intensely, all the time. Then, for example, the café we know suddenly changes—perhaps a row of potted plants appears, a tall chair is added with a uniformed guard sitting atop it, holding a black metal rod (let’s imagine the faint sound of a threatening hum). Suddenly, terror ‘redesigns’ the street we were once so familiar with. A few years later, the guard and his tall chair become ‘invisible’; we no longer notice them. Just as we no longer notice the surveillance cameras scattered in every alleyway of Jerusalem’s Old City.

At an international design conference in Aspen, Colorado in 2003, I presented a photographic journey of my commute from Shoham to the Bezalel Academy—150 consecutive images. In every photo where there was a guard post, I marked a red circle. There were nearly 30 such circles. This visual map conveyed to the hundreds of designers in the room what daily life in Israel was like under the shadow of the Second Intifada. These Israeli checkpoint structures were, after all, ‘designed’—not necessarily by professional designers, but by people whose decisions reflected Israeli identity. In another country, these same structures would have looked entirely different. The ‘Israeli-ness’ of that era is etched into every detail of these checkpoints, guard posts, and transitional zones. Around that time, vertical bollards began appearing in front of soldier hitchhiking posts, intended to prevent car-ramming attacks. When I asked the audience what the function of the bollards was, there was silence. No one could answer—because the concepts of a soldier’s hitchhiking post or a car-ramming attack do not exist in their vocabulary of everyday experience.”

D.A. During the years when Israeli society was experiencing heightened terrorism, you served as Head of the Department of Industrial Design at Bezalel. Did you feel that this reality should—or even could—be reflected in the design curriculum?

E.T. “During my first term as department head, there was a momentary renaissance in Israeli-Palestinian relations. The peace process had accelerated, culminating in the lead-up to the Camp David summit. There were wild, imaginative dreams about the potential shared future of both peoples. In 1997, I invited Paola Antonelli, the design curator at MoMA in New York, to give a seminar. We toured the Old City and exited through the Muslim Quarter toward Damascus Gate. As we left the gate, stones were thrown and border police responded with rubber bullets. We watched from cover and eventually fled the area, crouched and running.

Later, during the seminar, Paola asked the students to propose ideas for a design exhibition around the Old City. One student suggested hanging objects along the wall—an exhibition titled ‘The Wall of the Old City.’

In that optimistic period, a group of lecturers and I, along with Ami Steinitz (who was running a design and art gallery throughout the Palestinian Authority at the time), visited Palestinian producers, designers, and architects. From these encounters emerged a joint exhibition titled A Middle Eastern Exhibition, which explored the shared visual language we observed in Middle Eastern restaurants across Israel and the Palestinian territories. The underlying idea was to show that a new and original design language existed across both cultures—one rooted in the region itself.

During my second term as department head, I launched a project titled Bodyguard, in collaboration with students (who devoted part of their coursework to it) and faculty members. We developed an exhibition focused on head protection in the event of chemical or biological terrorist attacks. The goal was to explore head protection both physiologically and symbolically—through the lens of culture and meaning. About 40 projects were presented in a Tel Aviv gallery in the Salame neighborhood. Later, the project was submitted to the Museum of Modern Art’s 2005 exhibition SAFE: Design Takes on Risk, and seven works were selected for display.

In another project in Milan, the department was invited to present a restaurant concept. We chose the theme of Seam Line, based on the idea that Israel exists on many kinds of borders—literal, cultural, political. As a provocation, we served wine from the Golan Heights.

D.A. Have you ever found your daily life as a designer disrupted by a political event?

E.T. I began my design career just before the First Gulf War. My initial projects included designing cooling suits for tank operators and gas masks for the military. From the outset, I found myself entangled in the political and military realities of the region. Designing life-support systems captivated me—not only for the technical challenge but for the opportunity to help soldiers and civilians function under stress. But following the assassination of Prime Minister Rabin, I began searching for a different form of expression. I left that entire side of design behind—completely and without regret—leaving it to others. That was also the beginning of Israel’s high-tech boom, which brought with it a host of exciting new opportunities. One particularly interesting political project involved a collaboration with a Jordanian partner, supported by the BIRD Foundation, aimed at improving the efficiency of email communication.

The October 2000 Intifada was a deeply traumatic experience for me. On the very day it broke out, I was in the Galilee attending a seminar with international guests. The scenes of northern roads strewn with rocks and burning tires were difficult for our guests, as we struggled to get them to the airport—what should have been a short journey took seven hours. For me, it left a lasting mark of pessimism that I hadn’t known before. At the time, I was a partner in the Israeli branch of the American design firm IDEO, and the outbreak of the Intifada felt like the bursting of a bubble—well before anyone officially declared it so. I had a sense that everything was about to go downhill, and unfortunately, I wasn’t wrong. My response to this feeling took the form of an exhibition called Vanishing Wax, centered around one of the lowest-tech products imaginable: wax candles. I sought a humble object to express a kind of lament—a mourning for the hope that had just shattered. I predicted that this hope would not return to the region anytime soon.

A few months after 9/11, I presented a design installation titled Twins at the Tel Aviv Museum of Art. It explored the relationship between terror and genetic duplication. The work was anchored in my own autobiographical fact: I am an identical twin. I used the symbol of the Twin Towers—now destroyed—and juxtaposed it with the newly revealed possibilities of the human genome and genetic cloning. As a twin, I experience the reality of living alongside a genetically identical person every day. The terrorists who carried out the 9/11 attacks chose the Twin Towers for a reason. The way terror attempts to replicate itself, alongside the mirrored images of my brother and me, created a powerful metaphorical backdrop for the piece.

In 2003, I exhibited New-Baghdad Table, a work that branded me as a “political designer” within the global design arena. The project was featured in over 40 design magazines worldwide, and even now—nearly four years later—it continues to appear in exhibitions and articles. On one hand, it was published in The New York Times Magazine; on the other hand, several American museum curators chose to censor the work, fearing it might upset their donors. 

In my latest installation, Per-Capita, which will premiere in October 2007 in Istanbul, I explore the new forces of globalization as they relate to the shaping of personal identity, nationalism, community, and our connection to place.

D.A. Do you believe that design can ever be entirely detached from the social context in which it is created?

Yes, it can be detached. But even that detachment becomes a meaningful lens through which to understand the society from which the design emerged.

For example, there are Israeli designers who create as if they were living in the western United States. This detachment stems from a worldview that sees Israel as a floating island—one that might, in the morning, sit alongside Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, and Egypt, but by evening be tethered to the coast of New York or California as business hours begin. What shapes this environment are new global market forces that have made remarkable advances in the technological realm. This Californian aesthetic, transplanted into Israel, connects with a few tens of thousands of high-tech professionals whose way of life is fundamentally different from those outside that bubble.

Another example is the retail chain of Michal Negrin. She succeeded in crafting a neo-romantic decorative style rooted in pre-WWII Europe, and from Israel, built an international design empire with products and boutiques spread across the globe. Her design is entirely disconnected from anything overtly Israeli or local. Yet, a deeper analysis reveals that this disconnection has very Israeli roots—particularly among European Jews for whom the ‘perfect’ European past was shattered by war. Their nostalgia gave rise to a romanticized revival that took form in her work.

Consider also the red-tiled roofs of Jewish settlements, in contrast with the flat rooftops and vine-covered pergolas in Arab villages, or the use of ‘rustic’ aesthetics in Israeli suburban housing. All of these seemingly detached or artificial expressions offer a rich field for analyzing the longings, deprivations, and frustrations that fuel such aesthetic choices.

On the global stage, the detachment is even more stark. While the world undergoes massive social and political upheavals, the design world largely turns its back, refusing to engage. This reflects how the affluent world has disengaged from its ‘backyard’, essentially saying: “I don’t want to deal with the world’s problems—they’re too complex for me.” The design expression of that retreat is the unashamed surge of luxury goods, utopian design, organic forms, and overly polished aesthetics. Designers like Karim Rashid have become symbols of this escapist impulse. The obsession with the self has taken center stage, and the celebrity designer has become a cultural icon. Today’s consumer wants to say aloud the name of the designer who created the chair they’re sitting on.

D.A. How do you define autonomous design? Can you give an example?

E.T. Autonomous design is, in essence, an oxymoron. Design has never aspired to be autonomous—it depends on the user, the manufacturer, the consumer, the client, and other actors in the economic food chain. This is where design holds an advantage over art: it does not pretend. It doesn’t wear the robe of moral purity or claim to be ‘free’ or ‘autonomous’. Perhaps because of this, design is more immune to self-censorship than art.

Art produces commodities just like design, but in the economic marketplace, it gets an added layer of symbolic ‘greatness’ that design usually lacks. When design responds to a brief, it operates autonomously within the brief. The more rigid the brief, the less autonomy the designer seems to have. A classic example is a brief that says, “Look at the competitor and do something just like it—but slightly different. 

When there is no client and the designer develops something from their own creative drive, the process may appear more autonomous. In Israel, there are very few furniture manufacturers—and even those rarely hire designers, preferring to copy models seen at global trade fairs or in design magazines. As a result, Israeli designers operate in near-total autonomy. There’s hardly anyone to manufacture what they design. Nor is there a robust culture of design collecting—so even the most experimental works are not created for collectors or gallery owners. In that sense, Israeli designers are perhaps more autonomous than their counterparts in design-saturated countries like Italy or Scandinavia.

D.A. How do you define commissioned or ideologically-driven design? Can you give an example? 

Because most design is, by nature, goal-driven and purpose-oriented, one hardly needs examples—it’s all around us. When a designer creates a collection for a company, they must align themselves with the brand and its values. In that sense, they are already ‘enlisted’ to a cause. That said, the reason companies often turn to freelance designers is because their in-house teams may be too deeply embedded in the brand to see outside of it or challenge it.

There are graphic designers who will eagerly design a campaign for a political party they wouldn’t vote for even at gunpoint—but they wouldn’t miss the chance to create its logo or bumper sticker.

In Israel, massive budgets have been—and continue to be—funneled into military R&D. Artists are absent from this domain, but few senior designers in Israel have never worked on defense-related projects. Cockpits, gunsights, rifles, bulletproof vests, helmets—these are all designed by industrial designers. One can critique this on ideological or moral grounds, but within the world of design, it is accepted practice. Personally, I’ve never agreed to design weapons. Even when I worked with the defense establishment, I focused solely on life-support systems. Still, I would find it difficult to build a logically watertight argument against a designer taking on such work. After all, even a sleek Ferrari can be a deadly weapon on the road. For me, it’s a purely emotional stance—I simply cannot channel my design energy into crafting a rifle.

D.A. Is there a difference, in your view, between commissioned art and commissioned design?

There is a prevailing expectation that artists should express their personal views and sensibilities free from any allegiance to institutional or commercial forces—that they are meant to be ‘free’ and nonconformist. I don’t agree with that expectation. I think it can be harmful to art. This kind of avant-gardism is no longer avant-garde, because we live in a culture where conformity isn’t as obvious or oppressive as it once was, back when modern art was emerging. Even the word modern is no longer modern. So the desire to conscript art to some notion of ‘freedom’ feels outdated and inauthentic to me.

In contrast, commissioned design isn’t a dirty word in our field. As a designer, I’m always aware of what I’m committing to—and that awareness makes it easier to make choices. I’ve turned down many projects because I didn’t want to ‘enlist’ myself to them. Either they were intellectually stifling or ethically problematic—sometimes ecologically so. I know quite a few designers and studios who have turned down prestigious commissions for ethical reasons. I have enormous respect for designers who include an ethical compass in their decision-making.

D.A. Are there designers who, in your view, have responded to political realities with works of real significance?

One project that stands out is Cameron Sinclair’s Design Like You Give a Damn. He built an entire community of designers and architects who voluntarily offer ideas and planning for post-disaster zones.

D.A. Can you give me a specific example? What about that project spoke to you? 

The way Sinclair organizes competitions and exhibitions creates a powerful political impact within the design and architecture communities. After the tsunami disaster, he mobilized thousands of volunteers to contribute design work for the affected communities. His model is both practical and inspirational.

Share

This is a unique website which will require a more modern browser to work!

Please upgrade today!