Design as propaganda, 2009
Written By Ezri Tarzai for Haaretz Newspaper, 2009
The global media spotlight trained on Israeli design has induced government ministries to harness this success in an effort to add new sparkle to Israel’s tarnished national image. But despite the proliferation of exhibitions, the path to Israel’s recognition as a design superpower remains long.
Until two years ago, the government establishment had not yet recognized design, and particularly industrial design, as a significant arm of Israeli culture that ought to be encouraged, and its exposure assisted. Israeli designers did not receive any government support, and the general assumption was that designers exclusively served the industry, from which they derive all necessary budgets. But this perception is inappropriate when it comes to a large group of emerging creative talents, who work independently, creating unique objects; some even manufacture and/or do the design production of their own creations.
In the past couple of years, it has become possible to discern new harbingers of change: senior Foreign Ministry and Ministry of Industry and Trade officials have begun expressing interest in what has been going on in the field of Israeli design. The trend began with the La Fiera Milano design show in 2000, which was the first large international forum in which contemporary Israeli design was exhibited in a group context. After the show – which featured works by students at Bezalel’s department of industrial design, as well as the Umany, Yalla Design and Aqua Creations groups – the London newspaper “Wallpaper” identified design in the Middle East as the next big thing, citing Israeli design in the same breath as design from Lebanon and Turkey.
This sort of publicity often gives rise to a self-fulfilling prophecy. The breakthrough out of the darkness that until La Fiera had shrouded Israeli design, paved the way to prolonged international exposure, which is expected to peak this autumn, with no fewer than five exhibitions of Israel design being around the world in October alone.
One example is the roving Israeli design exhibition that premiered in Verona in October 2001. The exhibit, curated by Professor Vani Pasca and Ely Rosenberg, drew the attention of the Israeli cultural attaché in Italy, Yoram Morad, who was impressed by it and the positive media feedback it garnered. Morad then contacted every other Israeli embassy around the world, recommending that their cultural attaches take steps to host the same exhibition in their countries. Several attaches, including those in Prague, Riga and Frankfurt, did so. The exhibit opens in Lithuania next month.
A great deal of interest in Israeli design is now being expressed in Italy, Germany and Japan. Pasca and Rosenberg, in collaboration with Nirit Nelson, are the curators of a new exhibition opening next week in Verona; Nelson is curating another exhibition on Israeli design that is also opening next month in Tokyo, and which will then move to the design center in the city of Nagoya. And an exhibition of works by graduates of Bezalel’s design departments will be held in Germany, at the city museum of Flensburg, from which it will eventually rotate to Hamburg.
The public and media exposure spotlighting Israeli design has played an important role, in the face of the hostile environment and boycott threats that Israeli culture has recently come up against around the world. After having assisted in the staging of the design exhibition in Verona last year, the Foreign Ministry has begun to serve as the patron of most of the Israeli design shows around the world. Rafi Gamzu, director of the arts department in the Foreign Ministry’s division of cultural and scientific relations, states that the positive responses and media exposure played a part in the department’s decision to continue assistance for the design exhibitions this autumn, as well.
Gamzu says that an inquiry conducted by the Foreign Ministry among cultural attaches in Israeli embassies worldwide, indicated that there was no cultural boycott in effect against Israelis. Conversely, the study did cite a few instances of cancellations of concerts by Israeli artists invited to perform abroad, and projects that had been in the preparation stage that had been scrapped. “In Verona, we were asked if the participants [in the Israeli exhibition] included Palestinian designers, stipulating it as a condition,” says Nelson. “We eventually succeeded in convincing them that Israel should not have to decide who represents Palestinian design, and that we prefer a clear differentiation between the two entities.”
One difference between art and design, says Nelson, is that unlike design, in art it is customary to voice criticism and protest. But while prominent Palestinian artists are active in the realm of art, when it comes to design, there is no similar level of activity. “In design, the message is softer,” says Nelson, “and largely relates to the language of design more than to political matters. In this sense, it is less attractive to Palestinians.”
The Foreign Ministry, says Gamzu, decided to assist in the exposure of Israeli design abroad, in the hope that in light of its successes, other individuals and organizations would join as partners. “So far, the professional responses have been outstanding,” he says, ”and the audiences to which they are exposed are important to us. The fact that design superpowers are showing more interest in Israeli design is in itself both flattering as well as an indicator of the inherent potential. The main difficulty faced by the ministry in the past year was of a budgetary nature, and I am afraid that next year won’t bring any budgetary relief.” Gamzu admits that the export of Israeli culture, and design as part that package, is a strong factor in shaping Israel’s image around the world, no less so that a propaganda war might be. “Anyone who watches the reports filed by the embassies about the cultural events and their impact cannot help but be impressed that the export of culture is a proven source of dividends,” he says.
The Israeli design exhibitions around the world are amassing substantial cultural weight. The Israeli exhibition opening next month in Tokyo will be held as part of the Tokyo Designers Block project, or TDB (a copy of the British project called London Designers Block), which has been held in Japan for the past three years. Last year, about 200 designers took part in the project, and the 80 foreign designers included some of the hottest names in the field, such as Mark Newson, Karim Rashid, Ron Arad, Michael Young, Tom Dixon and Jasper Morrison. Israeli designer Tal Gur, who was discovered by the Japanese curator Treu Kurosaki at the London exhibition, was also invited to appear. Kurosaki, who was enthusiastic about the extensive design activity in Israel, offered to ensure that contemporary Israeli design would receive more widespread exposure to the Japanese audience this year.
As opposed to the exhibitions held in Verona, which featured several industrial projects from the realm of plastics and the Israeli high-tech industry, the upcoming Tokyo show will offer a showcase to unique projects that were designed in independent frameworks and were produced by the designers themselves. Nelson chose to present a wide variety of design approaches of creators – from veteran designers to recent graduates of schools of design.
Nelson argues that Israeli design is characterized by internal contradictions. “The three elements I have identified in Israeli design are pleasure, passion and pain,” she says. Rosenberg, conversely, finds the Israeli spirit in the fact that original design is not backed up by industry. But both agree there are elements of improvisation, the utilization of “ready made” (use of an existing object that is removed from its context) and emphasis of the idea, and less so on the ultimate form and finish.
But will Israeli design succeed in meeting its promise to be “the next big thing in the design world?” The radical Italian design that burst into the consciousness in the 1980s, the avant-garde Dutch design that offered an antithesis to it in the ‘90s, the French school of design, in the form of Philippes Stark and Martin Szekely, and contemporary English design – all are considered very stylistically defined, and their influence was and is evident in the variety of new languages they imparted to the world of design.
However, Israeli design is not stylistically uniform, and the recent arousal of interest in it cannot hide this fact. Its contents may be unique, but they to a certain extent remind one of design contents found in countries that have no culture of industrial design.
The exhibition of the Campana brothers from Brazil, now being staged at the Tel Aviv Museum, underscores the similarity between different peripheral styles: as in Israeli design, the Campana brothers possess a freshness and immediacy, with reference to “inferior” material culture as a source of inspiration.
As opposed to other arts, in the world of design, visual characteristics have absolute, decisive value. The ideas may be important, but the essence of the design must influence style, and this must be evident from afar. Therefore, so long as Israeli design is not stylistically identifiable, the integration of Israeli designers into the international weave will continue on an exclusively individual basis.
In order to create a new stylistic language, Israeli design cannot suffice with a banal merger of “East-West,” for example. In order to gain prominence, the new language must be different, atypical of the landscape and unique. Israeli design has still not arrived. After its initial turn in the international spotlight, it will be required to take a deeper, more reflexive step.