Menu

The Design Rush, 2007

The Design Rush, 2007

Written by Ezri Tarazi, 2007

“So what’s all the fuss about industrial design? Isn’t it unnecessary?” This is the question I’ve increasingly been asked by Israeli industrialists, especially following the publication of an analytical report by the Research and Economics Division of the Ministry of Industry, Trade, and Labor (MoITL). According to this study, 65% of Israeli business managers believe that industrial design makes no significant contribution to economic success. Conducted by Dr. Shuki Handels for the Ministry, the survey spans nearly 4,000 companies and factories—making it a powerful mirror of the prevailing mindset within Israeli industry.

A cursory glance at the report might lead CEOs and CFOs to conclude that industrial design is a waste of resources—more of a managerial vanity project than a viable investment. Why invest in sophisticated design processes when the returns appear ambiguous? What does this mean for the hundreds of industrial designers graduating each year? And how should design institutions like Bezalel Academy, Shenkar College, and the Holon Institute of Technologyinterpret these findings? Are they redundant?

Ironically, this report was released amid coordinated efforts by designers, academics, and industry leaders to persuade the MoITL to support high-quality design across Israeli industry—especially within traditional manufacturing and small businesses. Recently, Prof. Manuel Trajtenberg, head of the National Economic Council in the Prime Minister’s Office, joined the effort alongside Tzvia Dori from the Ministry’s Finance Directorate, to develop a national master plan for advancing industrial design in Israel.

A Sector Under Threat

A large portion of Israel’s traditional manufacturing sector is in crisis, challenged by the explosive growth of industries in China, India, and other East Asian economies. As with the textile sector in the 1980s and 1990s, many Israeli factories are being forced to shut down or relocate production to the East. It’s worth noting that nearly half of all employed Israelis work in traditional manufacturing—a sector crucial to national employment. While high-tech generates cash, it cannot alone create sufficient jobs. The collapse of traditional industry would widen social inequality to catastrophic levels.

In contrast, China and India have identified industrial design as a strategic lever for economic innovation. China has established nearly 300 new design academies in the last decade. India is investing in graduate and doctoral programs in industrial design. Both countries took cues from South Korea, which, within less than a decade, closed the quality gap with the West. The results speak for themselves—on every LG plasma TV, Samsung smartphone, or KIA vehicle. (Verganti, 2009; Julier, 2008)

Why Do Israeli Managers Still Devalue Design?

There is no single answer. But several interwoven factors contribute to this deeply rooted skepticism:

1. “I’ll Show It to My Sister”

When senior managers face design-related decisions, they often lack the language and tools to make informed choices. Their design vocabulary is limited to “I like it” or “I don’t.” Coming from engineering or financial backgrounds, most managers are unfamiliar with the cultural and subjective dimensions of design, which resist simple metrics. To navigate these decisions, they turn to relatives or friends—“design-savvy” in the most superficial sense—for advice, often relying on anecdotes over strategy.

2. “My Camera is My Chief Designer”

Many Israeli executives travel to international trade shows armed with a small hidden camera, capturing successful product designs created by competitors. Once home, they copy the designs—effectively utilizing design while avoiding the cost and risk of innovation. This “Me-Too Strategy” is seen as low-risk and cost-effective. But in global markets, particularly in Europe and the U.S., where IP regulations are tightening, this tactic exposes companies to serious litigation. Moreover, in fast-moving markets, copied products quickly become irrelevant. Following rather than leading ensures minimal margins and no competitive edge.

3. “I Compete on Efficiency”

Israeli managers, often trained in industrial engineering and operations, focus heavily on cost-cutting and manufacturing efficiency—even at the expense of product integrity. While efficiency is vital, there is a limit to how much one can reduce. When two equally priced products sit on a shelf, the better-designed one wins. Numerous case studies show how thoughtful design can reduce costs through clever material substitution or smarter production strategies.

4. “The Customers Are Conservative”

Managers frequently claim that customers don’t demand innovation—until a breakout product suddenly sweeps the market, defying all expectations. Few Israeli managers aspire to create “hysterical hits,” fearing the risk. Rarely do they engage in user observation, cultural trend analysis, or consumer futurism. The same manager who eagerly adopts advanced tech often fails to wrap that tech in the design language that communicates its innovation. Customers may be conservative, but compelling design breaks through resistance instantly.

5. “Designers Are Dreamers Who Don’t Understand Industry”

Many managers argue that designers make proposals divorced from manufacturing or marketing realities. Often, they choose designers based on price—not alignment with product goals. They treat the designer relationship as a short-term service rather than a long-term strategic partnership. As a result, many fail to absorb the designer’s vision or connect it to brand positioning and market trends. Designers’ strong intuitions, though not always grounded in present-day rationale, can predict the future of markets.

Symptoms of a Deeper Structural Problem

These mindsets form a cultural and strategic bottleneck in Israeli industrial development. For instance, Israel’s furniture industry suffers from a critical shortage of in-house designers and lacks a vision to become an export sector on par with Scandinavian or Italian furniture design. The few companies that engaged in quality design processes experienced economic breakthroughs. Unlike Europe, Israel has no royalty-based employment model for designers. In Europe, many top designers work on royalties—a model that transfers risk to the designer and allows small companies to engage world-class talent.

A small but growing segment of Israeli managers recognize design and innovation as strategic assets. For them, even modest investment yields high returns. These leaders understand that design is not a luxury—it is leverage. But such a shift requires organizational restructuring, a willingness to learn, and above all, a passion for design.

Apple’s success with iconic products over the past three decades wasn’t just due to its talented design team—it stemmed from Steve Jobs’ near-religious devotion to design. Similarly, Motorola saved its mobile division with a design-led transformation spearheaded by its chief designer (Brown, 2009).

Bridging the Cultural Gap

The cultural divide is widened by the fact that not a single Israeli MBA program includes even one course on industrial design. Israeli managers are unfamiliar with case studies like those developed at Harvard Business School, or research showing strong correlations between design and business success. On the other hand, many designers lack knowledge in economics and strategic management, rendering them ineffective in executive-level conversations.

The solution? Joint graduate programs in design management, brand leadership, and innovation strategy—targeting both designers and managers—can bridge these worlds.

A National Design Strategy

We must invest in R&D infrastructure for traditional industry, which employs large segments of the population and is key to exports. In most consumer industries, the primary form of R&D is design-driven innovation. Israel needs a national master plan to promote design R&D, increase support for design entrepreneurship through dedicated funds, and provide training and awareness to managers. Design collaboration should be institutionalized.

Industrial design is not just an aesthetic layer—it is one of the most powerful tools for revitalizing traditional industry.

References:

• Verganti, Roberto. Design-Driven Innovation: Changing the Rules of Competition by Radically Innovating What Things Mean. Harvard Business Press, 2009.

• Brown, Tim. Change by Design: How Design Thinking Creates New Alternatives for Business and Society. Harvard Business Press, 2009.

• Julier, Guy. The Culture of Design. SAGE Publications, 2008.

• Design Council. The Value of Design Factfinder Report. UK Design Council, 2005.

• Korean Institute of Design Promotion. Economic Impact of Industrial Design Investment, 2004.

• Fraser, Heather, and Jeanne Liedtka. Design Thinking for Business Growth. Columbia Business School, 2011.

• Papanek, Victor. Design for the Real World: Human Ecology and Social Change. Thames & Hudson, 2005.

 

Share

This is a unique website which will require a more modern browser to work!

Please upgrade today!