Menu

Improvisation in Realtime, 2001

Improvisation in Realtime, 2001

Written by Ezri Tarazi for the exhibition catalog Improvisation [Culture of Kombina], Ascola Gallery, Tel-Aviv, 2001

Link to the Hebrew Version  PDF

In order to delve into the essence of improvisation, one must operate within the very nature of improvisation itself. I look around. On the table lies a CD by The Cranberries titled No Need to Argue. I read the lyrics of the first track, “Ode to My Family.” I insert the CD into the disc drive. I listen to the lyrics and tell myself: the clue to the essence of improvisation must be here—and if it’s not, then I must improvise.

Whilst typing this, I open the CD booklet and discover that the lyrics are written in the illegible handwriting of the band’s lead singer and songwriter, Dolores O’Riordan. And this is how it sounds:

“Unhappiness / Where’s when I was young / And we didn’t give a damn / ’Cause we were raised / To see life as fun / And take it if we can / My mother / My mother, she hold me / she hold me / Did she hold me, when I was out there? / My father / my father, he liked me / Oh he liked me, does anyone care.”

It is a form of human arrogance (and later, specifically Israeli) to appropriate improvisation as an exclusive human trait. The human (and subsequently, Israeli) monopoly on improvisation is cast into doubt when compared with the extraordinary improvisation that occurs within what appears to be a “mechanistic” system present in nature. On the high peaks of Antarctica’s eastern mountain range, a lichen grows several millimeters below the surface of a cliff rock. For fifty weeks a year, it is exposed to freezing temperatures as low as minus fifty degrees Celsius. For two weeks a year, the rock layer beneath which it resides receives direct sunlight for two hours a day. This limited exposure is enough for the lichen to come back to life, grow, reproduce, and then wait for the next “summer.”

Apollo 11 left a camera on the moon, which was later retrieved by the Apollo 12 crew. When the camera was disassembled, remnants of bacteria were discovered inside—bacteria that had entered the camera on Earth during assembly, through the nostrils of a technician who had a cold. These bacteria could be revived despite having endured temperatures of 250 degrees Celsius. The force of life requires immense improvisation in order to survive under such extreme conditions, as attested by the hundreds of thousands of species and millions of subspecies that exist on Earth alone.

If the universe was not constructed according to a detailed master plan, but rather through open-ended patterns that allow for growth, then it demands from each of its components a high degree of improvisation to persist and develop, to continue and evolve. This might be the reason why humans possess a particularly high capacity for conscious improvisation.

Dolores O’Riordan captured in her description the plasmatic state in which improvisation occurs—for it demands that same mental freedom, that same sense of liberty that enables the emergence of improvisation. Not education, not programming, not old paradigms, not regulated templates, not procedures, not formulas. It appears to be a unique form of intelligence, one that arises under special conditions and is extremely difficult to fake or replicate in the same way. Its components are the joy of doing something differently in service of a meaningful purpose, accompanied by the knowledge that there is permission—manifested as support and love. The absence of any of these components amounts to the murder of improvisation.

A society that hates “the other,” that does not allow room for mistakes due to a pathological perfectionism, that fails to provide love or return appreciation to those who achieve their goals—but instead impales them for not adhering strictly to regulations—is a society where a culture of improvisation cannot flourish.

The laws of nature, in contrast to human laws, are rigid yet open to improvisation. Human laws are too often soft and malleable, adjusting to the socio-political climate, and are thus frequently closed off to improvisation. The more absurd and detached from nature these human laws become, the more rigid they tend to be. The conditions for improvisation exist in nature at every moment. Nature spares no means in order to evolve, and it contains within it open mechanisms that enable constant change and evolution.

Societies, cultures, and groups that have managed to maintain such a plasmatic state have experienced bursts of improvisation that enabled them to undergo necessary transformations. Yet out of ignorance, those who benefitted from it have not always succeeded in passing it on to the next generation, and so it fossilized into myth and disappeared.

The myth of Israeli improvisation originates in the IDF (Israel Defense Forces). It was born from a survival instinct rooted in an existential fear deeply embedded in Jewish history—one that lacked a military tradition. In any army engaged in conflict, there occurs a rapid evolutionary process of tools and methods. However, in the early Israeli military, where traditional structures were absent, these processes could unfold rapidly and consistently.

Israeli education was never based on discipline and obedience. It allowed space to create admiration for a kind of wild, semi-anarchic nonconformism—wrapped in a keffiyeh and khaki pants, with a gaze of contempt toward institutionalized authority. This era laid fertile ground for a culture of mental flexibility, creativity, and the amplification of values such as “creating something out of nothing,” “outsmarting everyone,” “daring to the end,” and constantly questioning existing data to explore alternatives.

In the 80’s Second Lieutenant A. used to wore a vest that had been completely dismantled and re-sewn by a skilled Palestinian tailor from Jerusalem’s Old City. The uniqueness of the vest was that it held four times as many magazines and grenades as any standard infantry vest. It is accurate to say that most infantry soldiers from Jerusalem visited the tailor’s shop on weekends to customize their vests. Not a single infantry soldier’s vest remained as issued by military supply. This “tinkering culture” was expressed in the self-design of simple objects like uniforms, field showers, clotheslines, vehicle and tank modifications, and the reconfiguration of U.S.-purchased missiles that Israeli engineers disassembled and reassembled. Consequently, many IDF units established their own tinkering teams, tasked with altering and updating equipment.

In the U.S. Army, the use of equipment without a ‘military standard’ certification is forbidden. This means that each component must undergo a series of grueling tests before it can be approved for military use. Ironically, this highly specialized equipment—often produced in small batches—is more prone to malfunction. During a major equipment failure aboard an Israeli Navy vessel, it was noted that a Sony consumer-grade video recorder in the crew quarters had never malfunctioned, despite being the only item on board without a military standard. This led, later on, to the legitimization of using civilian-grade equipment—especially in computing—something unthinkable in any other military worldwide.

The IDF’s improvisation culture created a broad infrastructure for industries that emerged from veterans of these tinkering units. In sectors such as textiles, electronics, and computing, a significant portion of managers were once R&D personnel within the military. However, this culture is gradually becoming institutionalized and risks losing the vital energy that characterized it in the early years of the IDF. Fear of failure, stagnant hierarchies, rigid procedures and standards—these are seeping into the formal military system and even into civilian industry.

The need that generates improvisation always exists. Contrary to popular belief, it does not have to be invented. Although life expectancy in the West is higher than ever and a decadent sense pervades the techno-economic culture—and design in particular—humanity is far from rest and peace. Decadence stems from ignorance, not abundance. For abundance, if not taken for granted and used wisely, can lead to a new flourishing. Yet the world, in the early 21st century, is mired in a fog of sensory numbness. It pays lip service to responsibility, but redirects the vital energy required for innovation and improvisation toward superfluous needs.

Where is true improvisation to be found? The mindset that Dolores O’Riordan so powerfully cried out against contradicts human nature and spirit. She longed for a different breeze, one carrying a liberated energy. At the dawn of the new century, design is searching for the space for improvisation. Will it be found in practical solutions to ecological crises? In new inventions for production processes? In indulgent luxuries for users? In intellectual tickles that stimulate the mind? In the expected cycles of fashion codes? In obsessive engagements with the perverse?

The space where true improvisation is needed lies in a new understanding of the open patterns of nature and the universe, and of humanity’s place within them. What is the role of designers in this task—among philosophers, scientists, spiritual leaders, and clergy? (After all, Judaism, throughout its history, specialized in remarkable improvisations. Yet paradoxically, in the period of its greatest economic affluence, it has become arid like a dried-up well.)

We must not think that a single discipline will yield the answers, but rather a systemic infrastructure in which there exists the joy of doing things differently for the sake of a meaningful goal—accompanied by the knowledge that there is permission to do so, in the form of support and love. Without all of this, we will only receive back everything that once was—recycled and vacuum-sealed.

Share

This is a unique website which will require a more modern browser to work!

Please upgrade today!